Fussy eating is one of the most common things parents worry about, and it usually peaks somewhere between ages 2 and 6. Part of it is a wariness of unfamiliar food that many young children go through. Researchers think it may once have protected small children who had just started exploring from eating something harmful. Today it mostly shows up as a meltdown over the wrong-shaped toast.
The good news: for most children it is a phase, and the way you respond makes a real difference to how quickly it passes.
What works: tiny tastes, many times
In a UK trial, parents offered their child a tiny taste of a vegetable the child disliked, every day for 14 days. By the end, those children liked the vegetable more and ate more of it than children who weren’t given the daily tastes (Wardle and colleagues, 2003). Nothing clever, no hiding it in sauce. Just small, repeated, low-pressure contact with the food.
What backfires: pressure
“Just one more bite” feels harmless. The evidence says otherwise. In a study of preschoolers, children ate significantly more soup when they were not pressured to finish it, and made far fewer negative comments about the food (Galloway and colleagues, 2006). Pressure turns the plate into a power struggle, and a toddler will win that one every time.
Try this tonight
Include one safe food
Put something they reliably eat on every plate, so no meal becomes a battle over going hungry.
Serve a tiny amount
A pea-sized portion of the new food is less scary than a pile. One taste is a win.
Keep offering, without comment
Seeing and smelling a food still counts, even if it isn’t eaten. Offer it again another day, calmly.
Eat it in front of them
Children watch what you eat. Enjoying the food yourself, without a sales pitch, is a quiet nudge.
Let them serve or help cook
Touching, pouring and serving food makes it familiar before it ever reaches their mouth.
Drop “one more bite”
Pressure reduces how much children eat. Let them decide how much, from what you’ve offered.
How much should they be eating?
Less than many parents expect. UK health visitor guidance for children aged 1 to 4 is three meals and two to three healthy snacks a day, in small portions. Small, regular meals mean there’s always another chance coming, which takes the pressure off any single plate.
When to talk to someone: if your child eats only a handful of foods, is losing weight or not growing as expected, gags or panics at new foods, or mealtimes are causing real distress, speak to your health visitor or GP. Most picky eating is a phase, but some children need extra support, and asking early is never a waste of anyone’s time.
Sources
- Wardle, J. et al. (2003). Increasing children’s acceptance of vegetables: a randomized trial of parent-led exposure. Appetite. Read the study
- Galloway, A. T., Fiorito, L. M., Francis, L. A. & Birch, L. L. (2006). ‘Finish your soup’: counterproductive effects of pressuring children to eat on intake and affect. Appetite, 46(3), 318–323. Read the study
- Health for Under 5s (NHS health visiting service). What’s a healthy portion for your little one?
Filed under: Food & Mealtimes · Ages 1–6
Seen our Toddler Food Critic? Follow us on YouTube: @SignalOverNoiseUK and Instagram: @signalovernoiseuk